Comparing Scholarly Journals with Magazines
Articles from scholarly journals, also called peer-reviewed, academic, refereed, or professional journals, are often required or strongly recommended by faculty at the university level for use in writing research papers and projects. This criteria is especially true for upper division courses and is essential in quality graduate work. These are some characteristics that distinguish scholarly journals from other periodicals:
|
News, Opinion, or Popular
|
Trade
|
Scholarly
|
|
|
Author
|
Journalist, freelance writer, editorial staff; might not be named | Staff writers, freelance authors | Researcher or scholar in the field; credentials listed |
|
Audience
|
General public | Specific industry, trade, organization, or profession; jargon often used | Other scholars, professionals, or students familiar with the field |
|
What is the purpose of the publication?
|
To inform or entertain | To describe issues, problems, or trends in the field | To report original research, experiments, or theories |
|
Are sources cited?
|
Sources may be cited or identified, but usually not | Sometimes, usually not | Always have footnotes or bibliography |
|
Who publishes it?
|
Commercial enterprise or an interest organization | Commercial enterprise, trade association | Professional association or commercial enterprise |
|
Appearance in print?
|
|
|
|
|
Examples
|
Popular: Hispanic, Jet, People; News or general interest: Nation, Newsweek, Time |
Advertising Age, Progressive Grocer | Harvard Educational Review, Journal of Marriage and Family, Social Science Quarterly, Theological Studies |
Research articles written for scholarly journals are heavily reviewed and revised before being accepted for publication. Guidelines for contributors are usually listed somewhere in the publication. Articles are often anonymously reviewed by several other subject experts; this process is called "peer review" and such a periodical is considered a "refereed journal."
Comparing Scholarly Journals with Magazines was produced by Diane Duesterhoeft at St. Mary's University.
Popular and Scholarly --thumb--
Looking for a specific article or journal?
Search by title to discover if the periodical you seek is one of the titles available online or from the library.
- A to Z Journal TrackerA list of digital periodicals (journals and/or magazines) available through University Libraries